Phones Samsung Galaxy Phones Tech Radar

The Galaxy S24 Ultra might lose its best camera feature but that’s OK. Here’s why

September 20, 2023
admin

Click here to visit Original posting

On September 19, popular leaker Ice Universe dropped a potential bombshell by stating that the rumored Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra may ditch the line's famed 10x periscope camera. Now, in a follow-up post, they offer more insight into what the next Ultra's camera system might instead include to fill the void.

One of the current Galaxy S Ultra line's greatest strengths is the versatility of its camera setup, it's why they consistently sit at the top of our rundown of the best cameraphones. Multiple years of refinement and a combination of sensors, including two telephoto cameras (a 3x and a 10x periscopic zoom), have meant Samsung's uber-flagship has been able to take quality snaps further than practically all of its mainstream rivals. It's the reason why – despite the unquestionable improvement to the new iPhone's cameras, as noted in our iPhone 15 Pro Max review – the 5x zoom on Apple's latest top-dog doesn't quite match what its biggest rival already offers.

However, when Ice Universe suggested that the Galaxy S24 Ultra may ditch its predecessor's 10x periscopic telephoto camera, we were left scratching our heads as to why now – with renewed competition from Apple in this department – of all times, the company would choose to nix what is one of the series' most standout photographic features.

See more

Thankfully, a new follow-up post provides some hope for those already lamenting the potential loss of the next Ultra's 10x zoom, with the above post on X (formerly Twitter) stating that the phone will still pack two telephoto lenses: a 10MP 3x zoom camera (as before) and a new 50MP 5x zoom camera.

Why this change might come about isn't exactly clear, although the physics of bringing a larger, higher-resolution sensor into the mix might have something to do with it.

There's also the aesthetics and ergonomics of this change to consider. As highlighted by the elaborate tetraprism that the new iPhone 15 Pro Max uses to fold the light for its 5x telephoto camera, the S24 Ultra might be adopting a lower-profile design than the Galaxy Note-inspired look of the last two generations, and to do that it has to drop the comparatively bulky 10x camera module we've grown used to.

Cropping back up to 10x

Even if the Galaxy S24 Ultra does make its debut with this rumored drop down to a 5x telephoto snapper, 10x optical zoom may still be within its reach through a trick that both the iPhone 15 Pro Max and the Xiaomi 13 Ultra – which Ice Universe mentions explicitly in this latest post – use: sensor cropping.

While the S24 Ultra might drop from 10x to 5x for its longest lens, this same rumor suggests that the sensor behind it will pack in five times the megapixels, giving Samsung far more room to crop in on the sensor itself and still capture a 10x telephoto image without needing a dedicated lens for it. Assuming the phone performed a 2x crop on that 50MP 5x sensor, you'd still be getting a 25MP 10x image, surpassing the S23 Ultra's 10MP resolution by quite a margin.

Take a look at how this year's Ultra's 10x zoom compares to its biggest rivals:

Image 1 of 10

Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra camera sample Google Pixel 7 Pro zoom comparison

(Image credit: Future | Alex Walker-Todd)

Galaxy S23 Ultra (top) | Google Pixel 7 Pro (bottom)
S23 Ultra's zoom range (0.6x to 100x) compared to the Pixel 7 Pro's (0.5x to 30x).

Image 2 of 10

Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra camera sample indoor light zoom 06x 1x 3x 10x 100x

(Image credit: Future | Alex Walker-Todd)

The versatility of the S23 Ultra's camera is bolstered by its outstanding stabilization and impressive post-processing, retaining exceptional detail and color consistency across its entire zoom range in well-lit scenarios.

Image 3 of 10

Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra camera sample natural light zoom 06x 1x 3x 10x 100x

(Image credit: Future | Alex Walker-Todd)

The S23 Ultra seems to default to matrix metering when using the standard photo mode, which usually yields great results but in higher contrast scenarios can lead to under or over-exposure of your subject (as seen in the 10x and 100x samples above).

Image 4 of 10

Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra camera sample Google Pixel 7 Pro iPhone 14 Pro Max low light comparison

(Image credit: Future | Alex Walker-Todd)

Pixel 7 Pro (left) | Galaxy S23 Ultra (center) | iPhone 14 Pro Max (right)
In very dark environments, the S23 Ultra handles night mode shooting very differently to its lead rivals, bringing exposure up, revealing more in the darker areas of a scene, but sometimes at the expense of color accuracy and fine detail.

Image 5 of 10

Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra camera sample low light zoom 06x 1x 3x 10x 100x

(Image credit: Future | Alex Walker-Todd)

Samsung's efforts in 'nightography' aren't just hyperbole, it's a phenomenal phone for low-light shooting, even if results are a little stylized. What's more impressive is that it can deliver across the whole zoom range, especially up to its optical zoom ceiling of 10x.

Image 6 of 10

Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra camera sample night mode zoom 06x 1x 3x 10x

(Image credit: Future | Alex Walker-Todd)

While the previous samples were shot with the standard Photo mode, the above were taken using Night mode and highlight that the feature is best used in more extreme conditions with less light to work with, as the telephoto sensors in particular suffer from a green tinge and more noise here.

Image 7 of 10

Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra camera sample moon 100x zoom

(Image credit: Future | Alex Walker-Todd)

Sure, it may be little more than a party trick, but being able to capture a shot of the moon – from the Sea of Tranquility (top center) to the Tycho Crater (bottom right) – like this on a smartphone, always feels like magic.

Image 8 of 10

Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra camera sample Google Pixel 7 Pro iPhone 14 Pro Max max optical zoom comparison

(Image credit: Future | Alex Walker-Todd)

Pixel 7 Pro (left) | Galaxy S23 Ultra (center) | iPhone 14 Pro Max (right)
Notice the color difference in the sky between the S23 Ultra and its biggest rivals at their respective maximum optical zoom ranges (5x, 10x and 3x).

Image 9 of 10

Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra camera sample colorful building zoom 06x 1x 3x 10x

(Image credit: Future | Alex Walker-Todd)

The (presumed) matrix metering mentioned earlier not only affects exposure, but color reproduction across the phone's various rear sensors. Notice how washed out the 10x zoom sample (right) looks, compared to the same section of the building at shorter focal lengths.

Image 10 of 10

Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra camera sample Google Pixel 7 Pro iPhone 14 Pro Max natural light comparison

(Image credit: Future | Alex Walker-Todd)

Pixel 7 Pro (left) | Galaxy S23 Ultra (center) | iPhone 14 Pro Max (right)
All three phones offer impressive detail capture at their maximum optical zoom ranges, however, in this example the Pixel's handling of dynamic range offers up greater detail in the darkest areas of frame.

As for the image quality of such a shot, that all depends on the sensor Samsung opts for (as more megapixels does not guarantee better quality images). For that, we'll just have to wait and see if Ice Universe was right, and to lay hands on the S24 Ultra's new camera hardware ourselves.

You might also like